Communalism
Why we need to revisit Shivaji’s idea of Hindu culture G N Devy jan 18, 2022 https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/shivajis-idea-of-hindu-culture-history-and-prejudice-7726717/ Text available at https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/shivajis-idea-of-hindu-culture-history-and-prejudice-7726717/
Shivaji celebrated Mughal rulers, had a cosmopolitan idea of India – unlike the Hindutva warriors we need to mute on TV.
Write Devy: I am aware that the present dispensation will not like Shivaji Maharaj’s analysis that Akbar was called “jagatguru” by people because he protected all, irrespective of their religion. Those who assassinated Pansare in 2015 did not like his description of Shivaji as a ruler interested in the welfare of all, irrespective of their faith. He quotes from the 1657 letter from Shivaji to Aurangzeb challenging the infamous jizya tax, “The Quran is a Heavenly Book. It is God’s utterance. It commands that God belongs to all Musalmans and, in fact, the entire world.” And further: “In masjids, it is He who is prayed to. In temples, it is He for whom the bells are tolled.”
Current Hindutva ideology is trying hard to establish that Hinduism is not the tolerant co-existence of faiths as Shivaji had interpreted or a way of life that acknowledges Ishwar and Allah as essentially the same. Going by the articulation of violence sought to be unleashed by the “dharam sansads” and the semi-official theorising of civil society as weaponry planted by the enemy, it is clear that Narendra Modi’s vishwaguru nation fantasy is poles apart from Shivaji’s idea of a jagatguru-ruler who professes no dharma but the raj dharma.
The RSS ideology of Hindutva, apart from being militaristic, is obsessed with tendentious historiography that sets aside all established scientific methods of reading the past and brings in untenable and wild pronouncements as historical truth.
It hitches together two entirely unrelated postulates. One relates to the question of the origin and spread of Sanskrit, the other relates to the Indus Valley civilisation. All available linguistic and archaeological evidence shows that there was no Sanskrit in India prior to the Vedas and our Indus Valley ancestors had no link with Sanskrit, half a millennium before its first appearance in India. The calendar also brings into the frame Adolf Hitler, without forgetting to mention that Hitler was “elected to power”. It asserts that the Vedic civilisation is the alpha and omega of Indian civilisation.
The concocted historical narrative and militant view of religion make this loud brand of Hindutva go against all that the Indian traditions of thought and spirituality hold precious in Buddha and Basaveshwara, in Kabir and Gandhi, in Charvaka and Ambedkar.
OPEN THE COLLEGE GATES, LET MUSLIM WOMEN STUDY!
https://twitter.com/BebaakCollectiv/status/1489961011214168064?s=20&t=B9NWHSMrPoxQ6BlISZ4aQQ
Bebaak Collective We strongly condemn the decision of several colleges in Karnataka to prevent the entry of women students into educational spaces due to their wearing of a hijab. This is one more addition to the aggressive policing of minorities that has become normalised under BJP. From the banning of beef, the disruption of people offering namaz, the passing of an anti-conversion law and passing the CAA-NRC-NPR, the majoritarian Hindu government in the Centre is going to every length to stoke communal tensions and discriminate against the democratic rights of Muslims in India.
We fully support the protesting women students in Karnataka, whose right to education cannot be denied based upon their religious identity and expression. Such actions deeply harm the plural nature of educational spaces and push people into separate educational institutions based upon their religion.
In the context of today’s highly Islamophobic political climate instigated by right-wing groups, the assertion of wearing a hijab becomes a symbol of maintaining the right to a minority religious identity, and displaying that right in a public manner. Therefore, the struggle of Muslim women to wear a hijab in educational and public spaces must be seen as a brave struggle against the diktats of those in power. In order to counter the onslaught on their rights, communities on the margin have mobilised themselves on the basis of their identity.
The struggle for the right to wear a hijab in India exists along with the struggle of many women to not wear a hijab or a burqa. The women’s movement has engaged with the question of gender equality, women’s autonomy from family and community, and the use of women’s bodies as markers of religious identity for all communities.
While there are many differing opinions on the subject, the fundamental difference is this- nowhere, in these conversations about reform, choice and freedom, does the option of the State or external agencies imposing rules on women’s bodies emerge as a progressive option. When women struggle against the wearing of a burqa due to their own internal critique of the community and religious practices, this has an entirely different significance. The decision about wearing or not wearing a hijab or burqa must come from Muslim women themselves, who have to negotiate a complex world between a majoritarian Hindu State and their own vilified community and public spaces.
We call upon all the colleges in Karnataka who have closed their doors to Muslim women students to open them again and take back their unjust rules.
-Bebaak Collective
Communal riots in India: Muzaffarnagar violence - Political leaders involved in inciting violence https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N4sjvdvzQio Sep 10, 2013
Communal riots in India: Muzaffarnagar violence - BJP Leader Hukum Singh incited Mob on 31st August https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ikjNM11RKgE Sep 12, 2013
The Kerala Story Review: A Super-hit Movie made for ‘New India’ | Akash Banerjee May 6, 2023 It’s been called cringeworthy, badly written, a poorly acted rant, a comically exaggerated propaganda …. But all the negative reviews are not going to stop The Kerala Story from winning over hearts and minting money at the Box Office …. Because this movie recognises what New India audiences want and gives them exactly that in a large serving …
Regardless of things like acting / script / story / facts - The Kerala Story will make a splash - here's why. This is a review of The Kerala Story and how the makers of the movie have understood the lust of 'New India' ..... If you want to know more about the fraud of 32,000 missing girls - then you can have a look at the episode we put out 5 months ago - calling out the lie ( now even the makers have admitted that 32000 was just a number) -
Is the story of ISIS can it be transposed onto Kerala, through the 3 stories? Story line has a lot of contradiction..
It also shows Hindu women as being so gullible and weak!
Shashi Tharoor EXCLUSIVE On 'The Kerala Story' Row https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w90AE8igkug 10may 2023
as PM Modi endorses the film and the West Bengal Government bans it. The film's trailer release had claimed that 32,000 women from Kerala had joined the ISIS when there is no such data to reflect this claim. The filmmakers then edited the description from 32,000 to 3. There are still 4 women in Kerala in an Afghanistan prison whom India has disallowed a return to after their tryst with the Islamic State. Tharoor says the movie's claims are absurd and mendacious.
The Kerala Story's true picture: 3 'radicalised' women, not 32,000
TNN / Updated: May 3, 2023,
According to the latest description of the trailer, 'The Kerala Story' is "a compilation of the true stories of three young girls from different parts of Kerala... Thousands of innocent women have been systematically converted, radicalized & their lives destroyed..."
In November 2022, the makers unveiled the teaser which claimed that 'The Kerala Story' presents the "heart-breaking and gut-wrenching stories of 32,000 females in Kerala!". The film slated to release on May 5 created a major controversy when it claimed that 32,000 women have left the state to join the terror group ISIS.
- Ashis Nandy gave a talk on hate regimes. Without saying even a word on Indian politics
- In India, the rise of an apartheid state
- In Maharashtra, a Gram Sabha Has Illegally Passed a Resolution to Boycott Muslim Traders
- Divisive rhetoric based on religion big challenge for constitutional ideal of fraternity
- Rethinking the role of communalism and institutionalized injustices in India- Yamine Peer