Webinar proceedings, presentations and press release on "Bt Cotton in India: Myths & Realities"*Experts stress the need to fall back on desi cotton varieties* With stagnant yields, rising cost of production and resistance in pink bollworm, India now can look back at the desi cotton varieties, experts say.
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/agri-business/experts-stress-the-need-to-fall-back-on-desi-cotton-varoieties/article32430732.ece# *Experts stress the need to fall back on desi cotton varieties* With stagnant yields, rising cost of production and resistance in pink bollworm, India now can look back at the desi cotton varieties, experts say. At a webinar on ‘Bt cotton – Myths and Reality’ held on Monday, Keshav Kranthi, who is currently with International Cotton Advisory Committee (ICAC), said Bt-hybrid technology has not been providing any tangible benefits to the cotton farmers. Bt cotton supposedly helped in the reduction of insecticide use. But the use of insecticides only went up as pink bollworm developed resistance to the technology. “Cotton yields are the lowest in the world in Maharashtra, for example, despite being saturated with Bt hybrids and highest usage of fertilisers,” Kranti said. “Cotton yields rank 36th in the world and have been stagnant in the past 15 years. Insecticide usage has been constantly increasing after 2005 despite an increase in area under Bt-cotton,” he said. The webinar was organised by the Centre for Sustainable Agriculture. Peter Kenmore, former FAO Representative in India, said that Bt cotton is an ageing pest control technology. “It follows the same path worn down by generations of insecticide molecules. Corporate and public policy actors then claim yield increases, but deliver no more than temporary pest suppression, secondary pest release and pest resistance,” he said. Andrew Paul Gutierrez, a cotton systems ecologists, pointed out that India could have easily learnt from the mistakes that happened in California in the 1960s and 70s, where the pest outbreak was mainly insecticide-induced. “The long season Bt cotton introduced in India was incorporated into hybrids that trapped farmers into biotech and insecticide treadmills,” he said. On Mon, 24 Aug 2020 at 11:19, Kavitha Kuruganti <kavitakuruganti@gmail.com> wrote:
In the context 20 years of bt cotton in India both legal and illegally grown, CSA and Jatan have organised a high profile International webinar was organised with four eminent speakers who worked on cotton experiences in India over last two decades.
http://www.kisanswaraj.in/2020/08/18/bt-cotton-in-india-myths-realities-brief-introductions-of-speakers-and-organisers/
The video of the webinar https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4o4clmQrDk
Dr Peter Kenmore's http://www.kisanswaraj.in/wp-content/uploads/Dr-Peter-Kenmore-Webinar-on-Bt-Cotton-in-India-CSA-Jatan-ASHA-24-August-2020.pdf
Prof Andrew Paul Gutierrez http://web.archive.org/web/20240629210324/https://kisanswaraj.in/wp-content/uploads/Prof-Andrew-Gutierrez-Bt-cotton-in-India-webinar-CSA-Jatan-ASHA-Aug24th-20201.pdf
Dr Keshav Kranthi's presentation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4o4clmQrDk
Dr Hans Herren's presentation http://web.archive.org/web/20240630083616/https://kisanswaraj.in/wp-content/uploads/Dr-Hans-Herren-Webinar-on-Bt-Cotton-in-India-CSA-Jatan-ASHA-24th-Aug.pdfINTERNATIONAL WEBINAR ON BT COTTON IN INDIA HIGHLIGHTS THE FAILURE OFTHE TECHNOLOGYNew Delhi, August 24th 2020: A high profile panel of scientists whospoke in an international webinar on Bt cotton in India presented evidence to show that the technology was ill-suited to Indian conditions and has failed to deliver on its promises. The Webinar organised by Centre for Sustainable Agriculture and Jatan was focused on an evidence based evaluation of 18 years of approved Bt cotton cultivation in India. Amongst the scientists in the panel were Dr Andrew Paul Gutierrez, Senior Emeritus Professor in the College of Natural Resources at the University of California at Berkeley in USA; Dr Keshav Kranthi, former Director of Central Institute for Cotton Research in India; Dr Peter Kenmore, former FAO Representative in India and Dr Hans Herren, World Food Prize Laureate.Speaking in the webinar, Dr Peter Kenmore said that Bt cotton is anaging pest control technology. “It follows the same path worn down by generations of insecticide molecules from arsenic to DDT to BHC to endosulfan to monocrotophos to carbaryl to imidacloprid. In-house research aims for each molecule to be packaged biochemically, legally, and commercially before it is released and promoted. Corporate and public policy actors then claim yield increases, but deliver no more than temporary pest suppression, secondary pest release and pest resistance. Recurrent cycles of crises sparked citizens’ public action and sprouted ecological field research by committed scientists. When this research is taken on by farmers’ groups, they create locally-adapted agroecological strategies. Their agroecology now gathers global support from citizens’ groups, governments, and UN-FAO. Their robust local solutions in Indian cotton do not require any new molecules, including endo-toxins like in Bt cotton”, he said.Bt cotton is the first and only GM (genetically modified) crop that hasbeen approved in India. It has been cultivated in India for more than 20 years, first illegally then legally. Political leaders and technocrats are often heard to be presenting a positive, hyped picture of Bt cotton in India. On the ground, farmers are looking for other crops or non-Bt varieties of cotton to cultivate as an alternative to Bt cotton.Professor Andrew Paul Gutierrez, considered one of the best quantitativecotton systems ecologists in the world, made a presentation on the ecological reasons as to why hybrid Bt cotton failed in India. He pointed out that India could have easily learnt from the mistakes that happened in California in the 1960s and 70s, where the pest outbreak was mainly insecticide-induced. The long season Bt cotton introduced in India was incorporated into hybrids that trapped farmers into biotech and insecticide treadmills, he showed. “The cultivation of long-season hybrid Bt cotton in rainfed areas is unique to India. It is a value capture mechanism that does not contribute to yield, is a major contributor to low yield stagnation, and contributes to increasing production costs”, he explained. Prof. Gutierrez asserted that increases in cotton farmer suicides are related to the resulting economic distress. “A viable solution to the current GM hybrid system is adoption of improved non-GM high-density short-season fertile cotton varieties”, he said.Presenting data on yields, insecticide usage, irrigation, fertiliserusage and pest incidence and resistance, Dr Keshav Kranthi who is currently with International Cotton Advisory Committee (ICAC) said, “A critical analysis of official statistics (eands.dacnet.nic.in & cotcorp.gov.in) shows that despite increase in area from 11.5% in 2005 and 37.8% in 2006 to a near saturation point after 2011, Bt-hybrid technology has not been providing any tangible benefits in India in the past 15 years either in yield or insecticide usage. Cotton yields are the lowest in the world in Maharashtra, for example, despite being saturated with Bt-Hybrids and highest usage of fertilisers. Cotton yields of Maharashtra are lesser than rainfed Africa wherein there is hardly any usage of technologies such as Bt or hybrids or fertilisers or pesticides or irrigation. Indian cotton yields rank 36th in the world and have been stagnant in the past 15 years and insecticide usage has been constantly increasing after 2005 despite an increase in area under Bt-cotton. Research also shows that the Bt-hybrid technology has failed the test of sustainability with resistance in pink bollworm to Bt-cotton, increasing sucking pest infestation, increasing trend in insecticide and fertiliser usage, increasing costs and negative net-returns in 2014 and 2015”.Dr Hans Herren who has an MSc in agronomy and plant breeding and a PhDin biological control, who is also a Laureate of the Right Livelihood Award and was the Co-Chair of IAASTD (International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science & Technology for Development) said, “GMOs exemplify the case of a technology searching for an application. To modify the genome of plants and animals serves only the short-term drive for profit at the cost of farmers, consumers and food security in the medium and long term. The technology is about treating symptoms, rather than dealing with the problem's root causes, i.e., taking a systems approach to create resilient, productive and bio-diverse food systems in the widest sense and to provide sustainable and affordable solutions in it's social, environmental and economic dimensions. Failure of Bt cotton is not just a failure of a product or technology behind it, it is a classic representation of what unsound science of plant protection and faulty direction of agricultural development can lead to. Bt-hybrid technology in india represents an error-driven policy that has led to the denial and non-implementation of the real solutions for the revival of cotton in India, which lie in HDSS (High Density Short Season) planting of Non-Bt/ GMO cotton, in pure line varieties of our native Desi species and American cotton species. The only way we as members of the earth system will survive and also be able to meet our SDG targets, is by transforming agriculture and the food system to Agroecology, which includes regenerative, organic, biodynamic, permaculture, and natural farming practices. We need to push aside the vested interests blocking the transformation with the baseless arguments of ‘the world needs more food’ and design and implement policies that are forward looking, deal with the Climate Crisis and help heal the COVID-19 pandemic aftermath. We have all the needed scientific and practical evidence that the agroecological approaches to food and nutrition security work successfully”.There are numerous genetically modified food crops in the pipeline ofapproval and experimentation in India and the ones waiting foremost for regulatory clearance for commercial cultivation include a new Bt brinjal event (other than Mahyco’s Bt brinjal EE-1), Delhi University’s herbicide tolerant GM mustard, Monsanto’s herbicide tolerant and Bt GM maize etc.The International Webinar was organised by Centre for SustainableAgriculture and Jatan, in collaboration with Alliance for Sustainable & Holistic Agriculture (ASHA) and India For Safe Food and witnessed the participation of hundreds of scientists from all over the world, in addition to farmers and other citizens.For more information, contact :Dr G V Ramanjaneyulu at 9000699702; Kapil Shah at
7567916751;Kavitha Kuruganti at 8880067772.BRIEF INTRODUCTION OF SPEAKERS
Prof. Dr. Andrew Paul Gutierrez FRES is Senior Emeritus Professor in the
College of Natural Resources at the University of California at Berkeley in USA. He was founder of the University of California Integrated Pest Management Program and Associate Director of the National NSF/EPA/USDA IPM Projects. He is CEO of the Centre for the Analysis of Sustainable Agricultural systems (CasasGlobal.org) with on-going research programs globally on various crop systems. He is considered one of the best quantitative cotton systems ecologists in the world and has been working on cotton and its ecosystems for over half a century and across five continents.Prof. Dr. Hans R. Herren, Founder and President of the BiovisionFoundation is President of the Millennium Institute in the USA. He was the Director-General of the International Centre of Insect Physiology and Ecology, Kenya until 2005; and Director Plant Health Division at the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Nigeria (1979-1994). He has been awarded, among others, the Right Livelihood Award 2013; World Food Prize 1995 and Tyler Prize for Environmental Achievement 2003. He has NAS and the Third World Academy of Sciences membership and is member of IPES-Food and the IFOAM-OI World Board. He was the co-chair of the UN and World Bank-sponsored International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science and Technology for Development (IAASTD, 2009).Dr. Peter E. Kenmore is a MacArthur Fellow (Genius Award) for his workon IPM in green revolution rice, former Head of FAO/Plant Protection, and former FAO Ambassador to India. Kenmore was the Founder of the internationally renowned Farmer Field School program in Asia. He had also served as Executive Secretary of Rotterdam Convention on Prior Informed Consent (PIC) in International Trade in Pesticides, an FAO-UNEP global treaty which coordinates the global programme on Highly Hazardous Pesticides (HHPs).Dr. Keshav Kranthi is the Head of Technical Information Section of theInternational Cotton Advisory Committee (ICAC) based in Washington, USA. Earlier to this, he was the Director of the Central Institute of Cotton Research (CICR), Nagpur, a premier institute in cotton research in India run by Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR). His main research interests are insect molecular biology, toxicology, ecology, immunology and biotechnology. Dr. Kranthi is the author of numerous publications on cotton and has received several awards, including the International Cotton Researcher of the Year Award, presented by the ICAC in 2009.
