SC Judgment on Zakia Jafri's Plea Seeks to Invert the Binary of Victim and Defender

SC Judgment on Zakia Jafri's Plea Seeks to Invert the Binary of Victim and Defender  https://thewire.in/rights/sc-judgement-zakia-jafri-teesta-setalvad The court’s concern that individuals at the highest level have to face questions of serious human rights abuses translates into a warning to those who raise human rights issues, while opening the window for them to be criminally prosecuted.

The travesty here is that the one who is trying to expose human rights abuses has, herself, become the victim.

The shock waves of the Supreme Court’s disregard for the tenuous position of human rights defenders in the country are being felt throughout India and many parts of the world. This reminds me of the treatment meted out to women who have the courage to speak out against male aggressors in cases of sexual violence. There are countless cases wherein courts have seen fit to stigmatise and criminalise the actions of women; in this instance, Setalvad has been demonised for having the ‘audacity’ to challenge the state.

In a true democracy, the role of the courts should not be to protect the powerful from the weak. Neither should the courts feel beholden to protecting the reputation of the state.