<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8" standalone="yes"?><rss version="2.0" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"><channel><title>Awareness of Prejudice on eMeets - Slow Long Knowledge</title><link>https://www.doccentre.in/emeets/q00-human-ideals/ahimsa/awareness-of-prejudice/</link><description>Recent content in Awareness of Prejudice on eMeets - Slow Long Knowledge</description><generator>Hugo</generator><language>en</language><lastBuildDate>Mon, 06 Jun 2022 16:23:02 +0000</lastBuildDate><atom:link href="https://www.doccentre.in/emeets/q00-human-ideals/ahimsa/awareness-of-prejudice/index.xml" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/><item><title>When workplace policies collide with the realities of DEI: Tanuja Gupta e caste issues and her sacking</title><link>https://www.doccentre.in/emeets/q00-human-ideals/ahimsa/awareness-of-prejudice/testimony-of-tanuja-gupta-full-text-of-the-google-caste-issues-and-her-sacking/</link><pubDate>Mon, 06 Jun 2022 16:12:51 +0000</pubDate><guid>https://www.doccentre.in/emeets/q00-human-ideals/ahimsa/awareness-of-prejudice/testimony-of-tanuja-gupta-full-text-of-the-google-caste-issues-and-her-sacking/</guid><description>&lt;p&gt;When workplace policies collide with the realities of DEI And how Google sacrifices women to keep order by Tanuja Gupta full text of testimony .&lt;/p&gt;&#13;&#10;&lt;p&gt;Full text &lt;/p&gt;&#13;&#10;&lt;p&gt;My career at Google has come to an end because of this company’s willful ignorance of caste&lt;br /&gt;discrimination, the double standards of its DEI programming, the weaponization of&lt;br /&gt;confidentiality to avoid accountability, and a normalized practice of retaliation against those who&lt;br /&gt;speak out.&lt;br /&gt;If we never had a chance to meet in the halls of Google during my 11 years at the company,&lt;br /&gt;allow me to introduce myself. My name is Tanuja Gupta. I was born and raised in Texas after my&lt;br /&gt;parents immigrated to the United States in the 1980s from India. By birth, I am half Hindu, half&lt;br /&gt;Jain, though I most closely identify as a Jain. After high school, I attended college at New York&lt;br /&gt;University where I graduated in three years and made the Dean’s List every semester. I worked&lt;br /&gt;full time through my last two years of college, and started my career in tech at the age of 20. I&lt;br /&gt;have since worked in technology for another 20 years as an engineering program manager.&lt;br /&gt;During my cumulative 11 years at Google, I have been promoted 3 times. When I was an&lt;br /&gt;individual contributor (ie not a people manager), I co-organized the Google Walkout to protest&lt;br /&gt;how sexual harassment and discrimination were handled at Google, going on to successfully&lt;br /&gt;advocate for ending forced arbitration within our company. Outside of Google, I have continued&lt;br /&gt;to advocate for both the Forced Arbitration Injustice Repeal Act and the recently passed HR&lt;br /&gt;4445 to end forced arbitration for sexual misconduct in the workplace.&lt;br /&gt;In April 2019, after Google ended its policy of forcing arbitration, I became a people manager for&lt;br /&gt;our Google News team. In 2020, I received that third promotion to “Level 7” and to date, have&lt;br /&gt;built a team of 17 reports. During my last performance review, which ended May 2nd, I received&lt;br /&gt;a rating of ‘Strongly Exceeds Expectations.’ I sit 4 degrees of separation from our CEO (me →&lt;br /&gt;Sr. Director → VP → SVP → CEO). Aside from being entrusted to lead several key initiatives for&lt;br /&gt;our 700+ cross-functional News team, I also founded a diversity, equity and inclusion model that&lt;br /&gt;became the blueprint for other teams at Google. After two years of building this program, I was&lt;br /&gt;co-awarded Google’s Search Superlative Award in 2021 for the impact of my work and this DEI&lt;br /&gt;model.&lt;br /&gt;I’m sharing all of this because everything you read below will come down to credibility -&lt;br /&gt;mine, the banned speaker’s, Google’s and my fellow Googlers’. It’s also a reminder that&lt;br /&gt;no amount of work success, number of successfully executed projects, or accrued&lt;br /&gt;credibility makes you any less disposable if you challenge the structures of power.&lt;br /&gt;One element of this DEI program model I mentioned is to run a speaker series, where experts&lt;br /&gt;from different organizations come speak to Googlers to educate them on matters of equity in&lt;br /&gt;different industries and countries. Since April is Dalit History Month, we wanted to shed light on&lt;br /&gt;caste discrimination. For those who are not familiar with this topic, the caste system is a&lt;br /&gt;millennia-old system of exclusion originating in South Asia. It impacts over 1.9B South Asians&lt;br /&gt;globally today, including 5.4M South Asians here in America. Dalits (the most oppressed in the&lt;br /&gt;Caste system) have been historically subjected to violence and denied access to education,&lt;br /&gt;healthcare, land ownership, and other social capital. Dalits are considered ‘untouchable’&lt;br /&gt;because they are considered ‘polluted’. And today, even though this sort of discrimination runs&lt;br /&gt;afoul of federal and local laws, Dalits, including those who have migrated to other countries like&lt;br /&gt;the United States, continue to suffer discrimination in private and public spaces —including tech&lt;br /&gt;workspaces, specifically Google.&lt;br /&gt;In September 2021, two Google employees approached me confidentially about the caste&lt;br /&gt;discrimination they had witnessed at the company. They shared the struggles they faced simply&lt;br /&gt;having a talk at Google about caste discrimination. I agreed to host this talk as part of our News&lt;br /&gt;DEI program and connected to them my direct report to execute. The News DEI Speaker Series&lt;br /&gt;was all set to have a talk about caste equity on April 18th with Thenmozhi Soundararajan, the&lt;br /&gt;co-founder of Dalit History Month and Equality Labs. Thenmozhi Soundarajan is a leading&lt;br /&gt;expert in caste equity and a Dalit herself. Her work led to the first Congressional hearing on&lt;br /&gt;caste discrimination in America, and her organization Equality Labs has been essential to the&lt;br /&gt;Cisco caste discrimination lawsuit. Caste discrimination follows South Asians wherever they go.&lt;br /&gt;So considering how matters of caste equity are covered in the news (or not) AND given the&lt;br /&gt;huge South Asian population in tech, my News team found this topic relevant and timely for our&lt;br /&gt;speaker series.&lt;br /&gt;However, starting two days prior to the talk, a series of actions, reactions (and inaction) started,&lt;br /&gt;leading to what I believe are retaliatory measures towards me and discrimination towards South&lt;br /&gt;Asian caste-oppressed employees:&lt;br /&gt;● Wed, Apr 13 - Fri, Apr 15&lt;br /&gt;○ A handful of Google employees send emails to myself and/or members of&lt;br /&gt;Google product &amp;amp; HR leadership at different levels with concerns, accusations&lt;br /&gt;and disinformation about the talk and speaker.&lt;br /&gt;○ Someone doxxes my direct report by posting her email about the talk on Twitter.&lt;br /&gt;○ I meet with my VP and Chief Diversity Officer, who collectively decide to&lt;br /&gt;postpone the talk and perform due diligence on the speaker. They also ask me to&lt;br /&gt;debunk the misinformation in the emails from a handful of Googlers.&lt;br /&gt;○ They promise to hold the talk once the due diligence is complete.&lt;br /&gt;● Mon, Apr 18&lt;br /&gt;○ Meanwhile, I host a talk with Thenmozhi off-corp so it’s open to the public - watch&lt;br /&gt;here on YouTube.&lt;br /&gt;○ I and several other Googlers donate to the speaker’s organization, Equality Labs,&lt;br /&gt;via our internal gift match platform since it is an approved organization (click&lt;br /&gt;here).&lt;br /&gt;● Two weeks pass with canceled HR meetings and no response on the information I&lt;br /&gt;have provided on the speaker.&lt;br /&gt;● Thu, Apr 28&lt;br /&gt;○ I post this email describing what’s happened to groups to reach ~8K Googlers,&lt;br /&gt;launch an internal site at go/caste-equity and invite Googlers to sign a petition if&lt;br /&gt;they believe the talk should be reinstated.&lt;br /&gt;○ I host another talk with Thenmozhi off-corp, with a much bigger audience this&lt;br /&gt;time - watch here on YouTube.&lt;br /&gt;○ HR asks my manager to submit a Talks@Google form as another form of vetting&lt;br /&gt;the speaker - to date, I have never heard back on the results.&lt;br /&gt;○ Employee Relations (HR) also reaches out to me, which I assume is to help with&lt;br /&gt;my direct report’s doxxing case.&lt;br /&gt;● Fri, Apr 29&lt;br /&gt;○ 400+ Googlers sign the petition, and multiple tech companies and activists send&lt;br /&gt;us endorsement letters of Thenmozhi Soundarajan (which are forwarded to our&lt;br /&gt;Chief Diversity officer and CEO). I post this email.&lt;br /&gt;○ I meet with Employee Relations, where I realize I am now under investigation&lt;br /&gt;because Google employee(s) escalated concerns about me.&lt;br /&gt;○ Moderators remove my emails from the industryinfo@ and pmtpm-discuss@&lt;br /&gt;forums.&lt;br /&gt;○ At this point, I’m tracking three separate investigations with different parties (i)&lt;br /&gt;Security, to investigate who doxxed my direct report, (ii) ERG PeopleOps, to&lt;br /&gt;investigate the proposed speaker’s credentials and vet the complaints of the&lt;br /&gt;Googlers and (iii) Risk Compliance, to investigate me based on concerns by&lt;br /&gt;people I do not know.&lt;br /&gt;● Two weeks pass, Dalit History Month ends and I hear nothing on the HR&lt;br /&gt;investigation nor the Talks@google submission. Meanwhile, my email spawns new&lt;br /&gt;threads that (a) deny caste discrimination (ex1, ex2); (b) label caste-oppressed people&lt;br /&gt;as less educated (ex); (c) contain Hindu-phobic allegations (ex); (d) make claims of&lt;br /&gt;caste equity reverse discrimination (ex); and (e) ask for my petition to be a survey, as if&lt;br /&gt;we should only hear about this topic from this speaker if the dominant majority group&lt;br /&gt;agreed (ex). At some point, the Moma search for [Equality Labs] also has a top&lt;br /&gt;suggested result with content from a known disinformation site. Another 200+ Googlers&lt;br /&gt;sign the petition to reinstate the talk with Thenmozhi.&lt;br /&gt;● Thu, May 12&lt;br /&gt;○ HR notifies me that I have violated the People Manager Code of Conduct and&lt;br /&gt;that I will receive a written warning letter later in the day. The investigator also&lt;br /&gt;confirms that if I was an individual contributor, this investigation would not be&lt;br /&gt;happening. They also ask me to take down several parts of the go/caste-equity&lt;br /&gt;site, including any reference to HR actions and specific statements by three&lt;br /&gt;Googlers - who will all be contacted separately as well. (One of the Googlers&lt;br /&gt;confirmed HR never contacted him.)&lt;br /&gt;○ Separately, the Head of Product Inclusion &amp;amp; Equity reaches out to me to learn&lt;br /&gt;more about caste as it relates to our products.&lt;br /&gt;○ Two hours later, in a meeting with my VP (pronouns: they/them), I find out that&lt;br /&gt;the person who is responsible for deciding whether or not we will have a talk on&lt;br /&gt;caste equity (and whether or not Soundarajan can be the speaker) has been my&lt;br /&gt;VP all along. And that they will conduct a listening session with the Hindu&lt;br /&gt;Employee Resource Group to help them make a decision. They also confirm the&lt;br /&gt;contents of my warning letter: my performance rating in the next cycle will&lt;br /&gt;automatically be lowered, affecting my compensation, and I will be ineligible for&lt;br /&gt;promotion for at least the next promotion cycle.&lt;br /&gt;● Mon, May 16&lt;br /&gt;○ I meet 1:1 with our VP, who says we should have the conversation on caste&lt;br /&gt;equity, but with a different speaker. I ask them to meet with the original speaker,&lt;br /&gt;Thenmozhi Soundararajan, to at least hear from her directly. My VP agrees.&lt;br /&gt;Right after, we meet with my direct report to break this news and make a plan to&lt;br /&gt;move forward where the DEI HR team will help us source and vet speakers.&lt;br /&gt;Read the full TRANSCRIPT here, PII redacted.&lt;br /&gt;○ I meet 1:1 with my Manager and have a conversation which cinches my letter of&lt;br /&gt;dispute, as you see a week later.&lt;br /&gt;● Tue, May 17&lt;br /&gt;○ My VP, Thenmozhi and I meet for 40 minutes, where my VP asserts this is not a&lt;br /&gt;legal discrimination issue and acknowledges Thenmozhi is being held to a&lt;br /&gt;different standard than all other speakers. Read the full TRANSCRIPT here, PII&lt;br /&gt;redacted. (If you read only one transcript, let it be this one.)&lt;br /&gt;● Thu, May 19&lt;br /&gt;○ After multiple pings, I recap to my VP, manager and HR that we have sourced&lt;br /&gt;multiple alternative speakers, but have been explicitly told not to reach out to&lt;br /&gt;them by HR.&lt;br /&gt;○ We also still have no understanding of the vetting process, or what was&lt;br /&gt;objectionable about Thenmozhi in the first place.&lt;br /&gt;○ I do not hear back from HR, and still haven’t to this day.&lt;br /&gt;○ I confide in a colleague who says to me “they’ve been waiting for an opportunity&lt;br /&gt;to do this to you for years”. This triggers my memory and I remember the report&lt;br /&gt;on Project Vivian as reported in VICE, where the end forced arbitration group that&lt;br /&gt;I founded is discussed explicitly. And I am the last Walkout organizer at the&lt;br /&gt;company. It suddenly occurs to me that the punishment I have received may&lt;br /&gt;have nothing to do with this episode, but that Google may have finally just found&lt;br /&gt;that opportunity to fire me without firing me.&lt;br /&gt;● Mon, May 23&lt;br /&gt;○ 11:15am EST - I dispute the warning letter (read 1,2,3,4, PII redacted) - to date, I&lt;br /&gt;have received no response with the requested information / clarifications from&lt;br /&gt;HR nor my VP.&lt;br /&gt;○ 11:20am EST - I formally request a legal investigation for retaliation and&lt;br /&gt;workplace safety (read 1,2,3,4,5, PII redacted).&lt;br /&gt;○ 6:00pm EST - I resign from Google. My manager states, “I had a feeling the&lt;br /&gt;second I read the letter … I think about everything I could have done and should&lt;br /&gt;have done. I guess I don’t see a full version of this story where I could have&lt;br /&gt;made you and Google happy.”&lt;br /&gt;● Tue, May 24&lt;br /&gt;○ My VP reaches out for a chat, asking if I have plans, offering their personal email,&lt;br /&gt;willing to make introductions to people in government and tech. When I ask,&lt;br /&gt;“would you stay if you had to sign that letter?”, they reply “I don’t know.”&lt;br /&gt;○ They also say that they will separate the DEI talk from the Product Inclusion talk,&lt;br /&gt;so it will not go through the HR DEI processes.&lt;br /&gt;○ My VP confirms, “I can run my product and engineering business however I like&lt;br /&gt;without HR involvement. The problem with this whole thing, sadly, has been the&lt;br /&gt;word ‘DEI’ in the speaker series, and then basically that gets into a world in&lt;br /&gt;which multiple groups feel like they have purview.”&lt;br /&gt;○ Lawyers from Alphabet - not HR from Google - reach out to start the investigation&lt;br /&gt;of retaliation. They ask for my lawyer’s contact information.&lt;br /&gt;● Wed, May 25&lt;br /&gt;○ My direct report, my manager, my VP and I meet to discuss a status update, my&lt;br /&gt;VP resharing what they shared the day prior.&lt;br /&gt;○ My VP confirms that they have ‘laid the groundwork with the Hindu ERG’, and&lt;br /&gt;‘we should be careful about the language we use in the future’.&lt;br /&gt;○ Speakers on caste will be vetted by Central Compliance rather than HR, but the&lt;br /&gt;vetting criteria and process is unknown (still haven’t received the objectionable&lt;br /&gt;material on the original speaker to date).&lt;br /&gt;○ We hold on reaching out to the nine alternative speakers while our VP confirms&lt;br /&gt;a) whether the vetting process will be behind the scenes or involves an interview&lt;br /&gt;with the prospective speaker and b) whether Thenmozhi will be sent through this&lt;br /&gt;process or not (my VP wants to think about it).&lt;br /&gt;■ During this whole process, Thenmozhi sources these speaker options for&lt;br /&gt;us due to her desire to ensure Google still has the caste equity talk.&lt;br /&gt;However, the majority of the prospective candidates are not Dalit nor&lt;br /&gt;South Asian.&lt;br /&gt;○ Read the full TRANSCRIPT here, PII redacted.&lt;br /&gt;● Thu, May 26&lt;br /&gt;○ Comms go out to the News team about my departure.&lt;br /&gt;○ We also learn that the new vetting process, steps still unknown, will be discussed&lt;br /&gt;at Google Leads the Tue, May 31st. (see here).&lt;br /&gt;● Tue, May 31&lt;br /&gt;○ Asian Pacific American Heritage Month is over.&lt;br /&gt;○ I have no update on the new vetting process.&lt;br /&gt;○ I still have not received the specific social media posts that made Thenmozhi&lt;br /&gt;unacceptable in the first place.&lt;br /&gt;○ The contract for Thenmozhi has still not been upheld.&lt;br /&gt;○ The person who doxxed my direct report has still not been found.&lt;br /&gt;○ A separate talk about caste by HR is being planned with a non-Dalit, non-South&lt;br /&gt;Asian speaker.&lt;br /&gt;The above are the verifiable facts, but I’d like to share some personal conclusions. As I do,&lt;br /&gt;remember that Alphabet (Google) is like a nation-state. Our executive leadership changes less&lt;br /&gt;frequently than US elected officials, and our market cap value of $1.45 trillion rivals the GDP of&lt;br /&gt;countries like Canada, Australia or South Korea. Bear this power in mind when you consider the&lt;br /&gt;weight of Google’s choices.&lt;br /&gt;1. Retaliation is a normalized Google practice to handle internal criticism, and&lt;br /&gt;women take the hit. It is no secret that women are often tasked with matters of&lt;br /&gt;diversity, equity and inclusion in corporate America. We are also often the ones who&lt;br /&gt;raise our hands too, perhaps because we’re often disproportionately affected by the lack&lt;br /&gt;of diversity, equity and inclusion. However, it feels increasingly unsafe to work in this&lt;br /&gt;space. In this particular case, four women of color (me, my two direct reports, and&lt;br /&gt;Thenmozhi Soundarajan), were harassed and/or silenced. Before us, April Curley was&lt;br /&gt;terminated in 2020, after she vocally opposed and called for reform of the double&lt;br /&gt;standards Google imposed on Black employees and applicants. Timnit Gebru was&lt;br /&gt;terminated in December 2020 after she criticized the company’s approach to minority&lt;br /&gt;hiring and published a research paper pointing out the bias flaws in a new AI system for&lt;br /&gt;learning languages. Margaret Mitchell, Gebru’s colleague, was removed for publicly&lt;br /&gt;denouncing Gebru’s removal and continuing to investigate the circumstances of her&lt;br /&gt;dismissal. Many of my fellow Walkout organizers have been dismissed or resigned from&lt;br /&gt;the company for their protests of Google’s sexual harassment policies. We’ve all been&lt;br /&gt;punished for our internal criticism because we’re “disruptive” to the workplace. But&lt;br /&gt;practicing equity is fundamentally disruptive because we’re trying to correct for structural&lt;br /&gt;imbalances rooted in decades - centuries - of injustice. And in particular, if managers are&lt;br /&gt;the ones with the power to enact significant DEI-related changes, but are bound by a&lt;br /&gt;policy that punishes disruption, how much does Google really want its DEI efforts to&lt;br /&gt;succeed?&lt;br /&gt;2. The machine of Google HR needs to be disassembled and completely rebuilt.&lt;br /&gt;a. First, Google policies are written so broadly that they can cover anything, so you&lt;br /&gt;have to question this selective enforcement.&lt;br /&gt;b. Next, since you’re told to keep everything ‘as confidential as possible’, you can’t&lt;br /&gt;speak out for fear of further penalties. Which means you can’t verify if what&lt;br /&gt;you’re being told is true or not. Google weaponizes confidentiality to avoid&lt;br /&gt;accountability.&lt;br /&gt;c. The very structure of HR is a shell game. All of these teams use different terms&lt;br /&gt;that obscure the fact they are all ultimately in HR. If you’re a Googler who is&lt;br /&gt;going through an investigation for the first time, you may not realize that&lt;br /&gt;Employee Relations and People Ops are HR. Or that the other teams you’re&lt;br /&gt;working with (ex: GSOC for doxxing investigations) are NOT in HR. And they’re&lt;br /&gt;all pointing to one another - or your management - for who has the final say on&lt;br /&gt;what.&lt;br /&gt;d. Now consider the fact that official DEI practitioners are being lumped into HR.&lt;br /&gt;Our Chief Diversity Officer, ERG Advisors and Diversity Business Partners …&lt;br /&gt;They all report to HR, and are constrained by the whims of HR. Why would&lt;br /&gt;anyone be a DEI practitioner if they aren’t ensured safety to conduct their job&lt;br /&gt;duties or gaslighted by the team that’s supposed to ensure safety for all&lt;br /&gt;Googlers? DEI without those protections is performative, and increases risk for&lt;br /&gt;everyone involved. Which is why my VP is working around HR to get a caste&lt;br /&gt;equity talk on the books.&lt;br /&gt;3. Google is woefully and willfully ill-equipped to deal with matters of caste&lt;br /&gt;discrimination, and that has led to the events and harm you’ve read about today. Of all&lt;br /&gt;the organizing I have done at this company, I think many are surprised that fighting for&lt;br /&gt;caste equity was the lightning rod issue that took me down. But I have an Indian CEO&lt;br /&gt;and SVP who both know exactly what’s going on and tacitly approve of everything that’s&lt;br /&gt;happened. I know this because multiple VPs and Directors confirmed that in Sundar’s&lt;br /&gt;Leads meeting, they discussed the need for a new universal vetting process of speakers&lt;br /&gt;to ensure this doesn't happen again. So my hope is that Googlers start to understand the&lt;br /&gt;magnitude of this issue, and the threat that their greater understanding poses to the&lt;br /&gt;South Asians in power.&lt;br /&gt;So what can you do?&lt;br /&gt;1. Learn everything you can about caste discrimination at go/caste-equity-learn. To get&lt;br /&gt;started: watch this talk, listen to this interview and read this article.&lt;br /&gt;2. Resist checking in with South Asian colleagues. Google has unwittingly just told&lt;br /&gt;every caste-oppressed Googler to go back in the closet, affecting their psychological&lt;br /&gt;safety, jeopardizing their future at the company and potentially their immigration status.&lt;br /&gt;Don’t put the burden of your education on the excluded.&lt;br /&gt;3. Demand that Google specify caste as a protected class in all locations (not just&lt;br /&gt;India) and that all managers are trained on what this means for the workforce. We&lt;br /&gt;recognize caste in our product policies (YouTube, Google), so let’s make sure this is&lt;br /&gt;recognized in our people policies as well.&lt;br /&gt;To the News team and all the people who reached out in the past week, it broke my heart to not&lt;br /&gt;be able to respond to your messages. I hope you understand now. I printed out each message&lt;br /&gt;(both public and private) and I will carry so many of you in my heart forever. No team is perfect,&lt;br /&gt;but our News team community was the real deal - banding together when it really mattered. I&lt;br /&gt;also hope you’ll remember that the retaliation I’ve faced is not a result of our News leadership,&lt;br /&gt;but of my management chain, HR and Google executive leadership. Direct questions&lt;br /&gt;accordingly.&lt;br /&gt;To my talented, compassionate, insightful and essential News T/PgM team colleagues - I'm so&lt;br /&gt;sorry so many of you got caught in the cross-fire. I am rooting for each of you always.&lt;br /&gt;Last, I know I am privileged to be able to write this letter because I’m leaving with the assurance&lt;br /&gt;of a future. The real victims are a) Thenmozhi Soundararajan, whose voice was stifled and&lt;br /&gt;b) the people who experience caste discrimination every day, but cannot speak out for&lt;br /&gt;fear of losing their immigration visas or being the target of hate crimes … or both. The&lt;br /&gt;fight for all of them continues whether I’m here or not - I hope you’ll join me.&lt;br /&gt;-- Tanuj&lt;/p&gt;</description></item></channel></rss>