FIR Doesn't Say Anything More Than SC Judgment

 

Teesta Setalvad's Plea : FIR Doesn't Say Anything More Than SC Judgment, Why HC Listed Bail After 6 Weeks? Supreme Court To Gujarat Police 1 Sep 2022

The Supreme Court on Thursday posed several questions to the State of Gujarat regarding the case against social activist Teesta Setalvad, who is under custody since June 26 over alleged fabrication of documents to file cases in relation to 2002 Gujarat riots.

The petitioner has been under custody for over 2 months. No chargesheet has been filed.
  1. The FIR was registered on the very next day of the Supreme Court dismissing Zakia Jafri's case and the FIR does not recite much anything other than the SC observations.
  2. The Gujarat High Court while issuing notice on Teesta's bail plea on August 3 granted a long adjournment, making the notice returnable by 6 weeks.
  3. The offences alleged are not serious like murder or bodily injury but pertain to alleged forging of documents filed in court.
  4. There are no offences which bar the grant of bail.

Chief Justice of India UU Lalit also orally remarked that the offences alleged against Teesta are normal IPC offences, having no bar on grant of bail."There is no offence in this case which comes with a rider that bail cannot be granted, like UAPA, POTA. These are normal IPC offences…These are not offences of bodily offences, these are offences of documents filed in court. In these matters, normal idea is, after the initial period of police custody, there is nothing which stop the

Sibal further said that the FIR could not have been registered in the matter when all the proceedings are in relation to the Court. When allegations are relating to forgery or perjury in relation to judicial proceedings, FIR is not maintainable and cognizance can be taken only on the basis of a complaint made by the Court concerned as per Section 195 r/w 340 CrPC.

"Of the offences 471 (IPC) is cognizable, rest are non-cognizable. The question is all the documents are filed in court. If there is an perjury or forgery, it is that Court which can file the complaint. No FIR can be filed. That is settled law...Kindly see CrPC Section 195. It starts with no court shall take cognizance of offences in relation to proceeding of court except on a complaint in writing by that court. So how can an FIR be filed?"

Referring to offence under Section 194 (Giving or fabricating false evidence with intent to procure conviction of capital offence) IPC, Sibal argued that "this can be done only by the Court. No FIR can be lodged under 194."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zV9QcwqpGlg Will Teesta Setalvad Get Bail from Supreme Court?क्या टीसता सेटलवाड को ज़मानत मिलेगी? Sep 1, 2022