Bail Hearing on Teesta

Whatapp Posts:  PP's submission opposing TS and RBS bail.. nothing but the observations of the SC in its recent judgement, and previous submissions of the state. keeps mentioning the 'wider conspiracy' already circulated all over through their affidavit - on the Ahmed Patel money issue and many more such stories.

.. the reference to TS having used ZJ as a tool in the 'wider conspiracy' is their USP..
PP is holding forth on her 'conduct' - the lunawada exhumation issue, her use of the media, Rajdip Sardesai named in affidavit and submission.

He went on for 3 hours on the following broad themes:
1. A historical overview of the ZJ petition
2. The 'conduct' of TS,  trying to paint her as a very powerful, dangerous conspirator through various instances he described....
3. The 'larger conspiracy' in which TS, RBS and SB have been implicated,
The following were the key points that the PP made in his submission:
He described at length, quoting from earlier submissions by the state in this matter and from the Supreme court order of 24-6-22, how ZJ was only a hapless tool in the hands of TS, who used her to further her agenda which seems to be to destabilize the then government through false insinuations and statements against the then CM, his cabinet and top officials of the government. He gave the instance of a statement made by ZJ having been written in such sophisticated English which even lawyers of considerable number of years of experience would not be able to comprehend. ZJ was tutored by TS and this was noted in earlier proceedings too. The PP said that the fact that TS was co-petitioner with ZJ, bears testimony to her sinister ulterior designs.
Some of the facts that we all know were presented by the PP as instances of the dangerous conduct of TS such as:
- Following the VHP bandh call on the 27th of Feb 2002, the bringing of dead bodies of kar sevaks was referred to in the petition as 'parading of dead bodies'.
- They alleged and propagated that Police were instructed to look the other way so that 'Hindus could vent their anger' in a meeting that SB claimed to be present in, but turned out to be false
- The allegation that the CM, Cabinet and Senior government functionaries conspired to engineer the post-godhra violence .
-TS et all even maintained that even the Godhra violence also could have been a part of this conspiracy in which the top functionaries of the government were involved.
- The allegation that military was called in late, and after being called in, not deployed.
The PP stated that aim of the accused was to politicize and sensationalize the 2002 crimes to further their 'ulterior designs'. Two of the accused are 'disgruntled' police officers and TS is a 'politically aspirant' lady.
On the conduct of TS the PP had two more instances to share. Throughout he was trying to say that she was a 'headstrong' powerful influential woman who could derail the investigation. One instance he stated was how she had forwarded her own letters addressed to the Chairperson of the SIT, to UN agencies in Geneva. The PP lamented, "What would the poor local Investigating officer do in the face of such operations!" The hapless investigating officer in the face of a scheming, powerful lady, TS was a theme that the PP repeated many times during his submission. He also narrated the whole case that was filed against TS in the context of the Lunavada mass graves and exhumation matter. The way the PP characterized TS's meeting the amicus curie in the ZJ petition was also interesting. He said that Raju Ramachandran, the Amicus Curie, was appointed to play his role as the 'friend of the court', but she did not spare him too, and met him, trying to influence him too! If TS were to be enlarged on bail, one could imagine how she would try to influence the course of investigation!
The PP also referred to the misappropriation case against TS and the case of violation of FCRA too.
The 'larger conspiracy' of TS, RBS and SB was to have meetings with political leaders of certain parties (without naming the parties and the leaders) and get assurances of monetary support for the sinister design to destabilize a government through false information and ulterior design. He mentioned once about Rais Khan Pathan and his disclosures too. He mentioned that there were 3-4 witnesses whose names he was not at liberty to disclose who were privy to all the incriminating information regarding this 'larger conspiracy' to destabilize this government by maligning through false information for which money also was received from certain quarters.
The above submission took close to 2.5 hours, and the court had no option but to adjourn. The PP said that tomorrow he would respond to the points of law (particularly the definitions and interpretations that Somnath had presented regarding Sec 190-195 and Sec 211 and some of the judgements that were cited both by Somnath and MM Vora). In short the PP spent time today basically in painting a picture of TS as someone who exploited the emotions of ZJ and used her as a tool to further the sinister, ulterior political designs; as a lady with political aspirations who can influence and derail the course of investigations.
There were no serious points regarding RBS except that he was a disgruntled officer, and that he worked with TS. This could be because there may not be anything except the affidavits in which he has made allegations against the then state government and its top officials in the Nanavati-Shah commission, which in any case cannot be used in any criminal trial. There was no tirade against RBS as in the case of TS. I wonder if it is because the prosecution may be contemplating not to oppose his bail specifically and focus on TS. It will be clear tomorrow when the PP makes the remaining part of his submission. As far as SB is concerned, his matter is being heard in a differe by Prasad Chacko (posted by MD)