https://theleaflet.in/the-outrage-over-denial-of-bail-to-teesta-setalvad-and-grant-of-remission-to-bilkis-bano-convicts-shows-it-is-not-easy-to-erase-recent-history/ it is obvious that the roles of both the Supreme Court and the Gujarat government have come under intense scrutiny for their omissions and commissions in the Gujarat-carnage related cases.
On Friday, 11 academics of repute, affiliated with well-known universities abroad, issued a statement expressing their dismay over some of the recent judgments of the Supreme Court having a direct bearing on the future of civil liberties and human rights in India. They drew attention, in particular, to the judgment in the Zakia Jafri case, which, they said, raises three disturbing questions.
One: since the petitioners had challenged the findings of the Special Investigation Team’s (‘SIT’) report ..for the court to dismiss their appeal on the basis of the very same impugned SIT report, seemed to them to be unjust.
Two: They expressed their dismay, by citing from the judgment: “If any patient, prolonged, peaceful, and entirely legitimate pursuit of justice through the due process, is called “keeping the pot boiling”, then this remark, quite apart from being offensive, discourages people from approaching the Court on any matter relating to excesses or dereliction on the part of the executive.”
Three: the court had passed these uncalled-for obiter dicta without even giving a hearing to those against whom these remarks are directed; this, they claimed, sets an unfortunate precedent in jurisprudence.
